Top 25 Must-Try Pizzas In New Jersey [2024 Picks]
Craving the best pizza in New Jersey in 2024? Our guide covers the most beloved spots across the state, with options everyone will love!
Aug 25, 202422.2K Shares308.9K Views
New Jersey boasts a vibrant pizza landscape that rivals even the famed slices of New York City. Each pizzeria in the state offers a slice of heaven, perfected by passionate chefs and pizza artisans. This guide presents the top 25 pizza spots across New Jersey, known for their authenticity, creativity, and mouth-watering flavors that leave residents and visitors craving more.
The Criteria For Our Top 25
Our selections are based on comprehensive criteria including the freshness of ingredients, customer feedback, innovation in pizza-making, and the overall dining experience. These elements help ensure that each recommended pizzeria offers something special, making them stand out in the bustling New Jersey pizza scene.
Top 25 Pizzas In New Jersey
Tony's Tomato Pies - Newark
- Location:Downtown Newark
- What to Try:The Classic Tomato Pie
- Why It Stands Out:Tony's is a staple of Newark, using a century-old recipe that emphasizes fresh, locally-sourced tomatoes and homemade mozzarella.
Bella Napoli - Bloomfield
- Location:Main Street, Bloomfield
- What to Try:Neapolitan Spinach and Ricotta Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Known for its thin crust and rich flavors, Bella Napolisources its ingredients from local farms, ensuring a fresh, farm-to-table experiencein every bite.
Crust & Crumble - Asbury Park
- Location:Boardwalk, Asbury Park
- What to Try:Vegan Barbecue Chicken Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Pioneering in vegan options, Crust & Crumble offers a unique twist on traditional pizza with bold flavors and plant-based ingredients.
De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies - Robbinsville
- Location:Suburban Square, Robbinsville
- What to Try:Trenton Tomato Pie
- Why It Stands Out:De Lorenzo's maintains a legendary status with its crispy crust and secret sauce recipe that has been guarded for generations.
Slice Of Heaven - Jersey City
- Location:Historic Downtown, Jersey City
- What to Try:Wild Mushroom Truffle Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:This chic eatery blends the art of fine pizzas with luxury, offering exotic toppings like wild mushrooms and truffle oil on a perfectly baked crust.
Pizzeria Uno - Cherry Hill
- Location:Market Place, Cherry Hill
- What to Try:Deep Dish Pepperoni Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Pizzeria Unobrings Chicago-style deep dish to New Jersey with a rich, buttery crust filled with layers of cheese and pepperoni.
Margherita Mania - Montclair
- Location:Central Avenue, Montclair
- What to Try:Classic Margherita
- Why It Stands Out:Celebrated for its authenticity, Margherita Mania uses a wood-fired oven and ingredients imported from Naples, providing an authentic Italian experience.
PieZano's Pizza Kitchen - Atlantic City
- Location:Boardwalk, Atlantic City
- What to Try:Seafood Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Located right by the sea, PieZano's Pizza Kitchenoffers a fresh seafood pizza that captures the essence of the ocean with toppings like shrimp and scallops on a crispy crust.
Vinny's Pizzeria - Princeton
- Location:Nassau Street, Princeton
- What to Try:Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Vinny’s combines creamy, spicy buffalo sauce with tender chicken and a cheesy base, creating a bold flavor profile beloved by locals.
Napoli’s Neapolitan - Morristown
- Location:Elm Street, Morristown
- What to Try:Eggplant Parmesan Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Napoli’s Neapolitan offers a delicious twist on a classic dish, turning eggplant parmesan into a delightful pizza topping.
Garden State Pizzeria - Edison
- Location:Oak Tree Road, Edison
- What to Try:Garden Veggie Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:This pizzeria specializes in fresh, locally sourced vegetables, making their Garden Veggie Pizza a colorful and healthy option.
Little Italy Pizzeria - Hoboken
- Location:Washington Street, Hoboken
- What to Try:Meat Lover’s Delight
- Why It Stands Out:Little Italy Pizzeria serves up a hearty pizza loaded with various meats, catering to those with a robust appetite.
Brick Oven Of Morristown - Morristown
- Location:South Street, Morristown
- What to Try:Truffle Oil and Prosciutto Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:This pizzeria uses high-quality ingredients like truffle oil and thinly sliced prosciutto to create a luxurious pizza experience.
Boardwalk Pizza - Point Pleasant
- Location:Ocean Avenue, Point Pleasant
- What to Try:Boardwalk Special
- Why It Stands Out:Famous for its thin crust and ocean views, Boardwalk Pizza offers a special blend of cheeses and fresh toppings that reflect the local vibe.
The Pizza Parlor - Paramus
- Location:Route 17, Paramus
- What to Try:Spicy Pepperoni
- Why It Stands Out:The Pizza Parlor spices up the traditional pepperoni pizza with a kick of hot peppers and a spicy sauce.
City Slice - Camden
- Location:River Avenue, Camden
- What to Try:BBQ Chicken Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:City Slice brings a tangy twist with its BBQ Chicken Pizza, which combines sweet barbecue sauce with savory chicken and onions.
Old World Pizza - Elizabeth
- Location:Elmora Avenue, Elizabeth
- What to Try:White Pizza with Ricotta
- Why It Stands Out:Old World Pizza offers a creamy, rich white pizza topped with dollops of fresh ricotta and mozzarella.
Metro Pizza - Newark
- Location:Broad Street, Newark
- What to Try:Clam and Garlic Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Metro Pizza introduces a taste of the shore with its fresh clam and garlic pizza, a hit among seafood lovers.
Sunset Pizzeria - Jersey City
- Location:West Side Avenue, Jersey City
- What to Try:Sunset Special
- Why It Stands Out:Known for its stunning views and unique pizza combinations, Sunset Pizzeria offers a special pie that includes sun-dried tomatoes, roasted peppers, and goat cheese.
Alfredo’s Pizza - Cherry Hill
- Location:Church Road, Cherry Hill
- What to Try:Alfredo’s White
- Why It Stands Out:This place is renowned for its creamy Alfredo sauce base topped with spinach and mushrooms, providing a rich and flavorful experience.
ZaZa’s Pizza Corner - New Brunswick
- Location:George Street, New Brunswick
- What to Try:ZaZa’s Zesty Zucchini
- Why It Stands Out:ZaZa’s introduces a vegetarian delight with thinly sliced zucchini paired with lemon zest on a thin crust, offering a refreshing twist.
The Stone Tavern - Trenton
- Location:Market Street, Trenton
- What to Try:Spicy Sausage Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:The Stone Tavern is renowned for its handcrafted pizzas topped with house-made sausage and a spicy tomato sauce that brings a unique local flavor to the dish.
Oven Fresh Pies - Ocean City
- Location:Asbury Avenue, Ocean City
- What to Try:Fresh Clam Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Specializing in seafood pizzas, Oven Fresh offers a fresh clam pizza with garlic and olive oil that captures the essence of the Jersey shore.
Pizzeria Grande - Paterson
- Location:Main Street, Paterson
- What to Try:Four Cheese Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Pizzeria Grande serves a decadent four cheese pizza that blends mozzarella, gorgonzola, parmesan, and goat cheese for a rich and creamy taste experience.
Artisan's Oven - Cape May
- Location:Beach Avenue, Cape May
- What to Try:Prosciutto and Arugula Pizza
- Why It Stands Out:Artisan's Oven combines the salty taste of prosciutto with the peppery flavor of arugula on a crispy thin crust, offering a sophisticated twist on traditional pizza.
FAQs About Pizza In New Jersey
What Makes New Jersey Pizza Unique?
New Jersey pizzas are distinguished by their variety and the authenticity of styles offered, from Trenton's tomato pies to Atlantic City's boardwalk slices. Each style reflects the rich culinary history and demographic mosaic of the state.
Which New Jersey City Has The Best Pizza?
While it's a tight competition, cities like Newark and Jersey City are often lauded for their high concentration of top-rated pizzerias that offer everything from classic to contemporary pizza styles.
How Do I Find The Best Pizza When Visiting New Jersey?
To discover the best pizza, look for pizzerias with high ratings and reviews that mention fresh ingredients, unique recipes, and local flavor preferences.
Can I Find Different Styles Of Pizza In New Jersey?
Absolutely! New Jersey is a melting pot of pizza styles. You can enjoy everything from traditional Neapolitan pizzas to inventive vegan options and hearty deep-dish pies.
What Are Some Common Toppings Found On New Jersey Pizzas?
Common toppings include classic options like pepperoni and mushrooms, as well as unique choices such as fresh clams or figs, catering to a diverse palate.
Are There Any Gluten-free Pizza Options Available In New Jersey?
Yes, many of the pizzerias listed offer gluten-free crust options, making it easy for those with dietary restrictions to enjoy a slice.
What Are The Best Options For Vegan Pizza In New Jersey?
Several pizzerias, such as Crust & Crumble in Asbury Park, specialize in vegan pizzas, offering a range of toppings from vegan cheese to meat substitutes.
Conclusion
Exploring the pizza scene in New Jersey offers an exciting culinary journey through diverse flavors and innovative creations. From classic tomato pies to gourmet vegan options, the state's pizzerias cater to all tastes and preferences, solidifying its reputation as a top destination for pizza enthusiasts.
Latest Articles
Popular Articles